Peer Review Process

The Journal of Economic, Finance Research and Review (JEFRR) is committed to a transparent, fair, and efficient peer review process, ensuring the publication of only the highest-quality economics and finance research.

Overview of the Peer Review Process

1. Editorial Pre-Evaluation

  • Upon submission, manuscripts undergo a preliminary review by the editorial team to verify alignment with JEFRR’s scope, formatting, and ethical guidelines.

  • The manuscript is checked for originality using plagiarism detection tools and is assessed for academic quality and relevance.

  • Submissions that do not meet basic criteria are promptly returned to authors with clear feedback.

2. Double-Blind Peer Review

  • Qualified manuscripts proceed to double-blind peer review, where both authors and reviewers remain anonymous to ensure unbiased evaluation.

  • The editorial office assigns each paper to at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.

  • Reviewers critically assess the manuscript’s originality, methodology, significance, clarity, and contribution to the field.

3. Evaluation and Decision

  • Reviewers provide detailed, constructive feedback and recommend one of the following: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject.

  • The editorial team consolidates the reviewers’ reports and makes the final decision.

  • In cases of significant disagreement between reviewers, a third expert may be consulted.

4. Revision Stage

  • If revisions are requested, authors receive clear, point-by-point feedback and a specified timeline for submission of the revised manuscript.

  • Authors must address all reviewer and editor comments thoroughly, submitting a response letter outlining changes made.

5. Subsequent Review (if needed)

  • Revised manuscripts may be sent back to reviewers for further evaluation to ensure all concerns are addressed and the highest standards are maintained.

6. Final Decision and Publication

  • Once the manuscript satisfies all scientific and ethical standards, it is formally accepted.

  • Accepted papers undergo final copyediting and formatting before rapid online publication.

Key Features

  • Timely Review: JEFRR aims to provide the first decision within 7 days of peer review commencement, with expedited publication for manuscripts that require no further revision.

  • Fairness and Confidentiality: The integrity of the process is maintained through double-blind review, impartial handling of conflict of interest, and strict reviewer confidentiality.

  • Transparent Communication: Authors are informed promptly at each stage and receive comprehensive feedback supporting research improvement.

Reviewer Recognition

  • JEFRR values the expertise and time of peer reviewers and recognizes their essential role in upholding academic standards. Outstanding reviewers may be invited to join the editorial board or serve as guest editors for future special issues.

 

JEFRR’s peer review process is designed for scholarly rigor, speed, and fairness—ensuring every published article meets the expectations of the global economics and finance research community.

For detailed submission instructions and policies, authors should consult the relevant sections on the JEFRR website or contact the editorial office directly.